Is Investment in Palm Oil Certification Worth It?

1499

Duncan GromkoEscrito por:

Palm oil has a terrible reputation. Especially among environmental and social advocates, palm oil is viewed as the crop responsible for a large-scale deforestation, particularly in Southeast Asia. Deforestation of carbon-rich forests leads to greenhouse gas emissions; between 2001 and 2010, palm oil-driven land-use change resulted in an average of 216-268 million tons of CO2 equivalent per year in Indonesia alone. For some perspective, that’s equivalent to the emissions from driving more than 45 million cars over the course of a year! Evidence also suggests labor rights violations, including child labor, at many plantations.

planation and pile

Palm oil plantation in Ecuador

On the other hand, simply vilifying palm oil and the people who produce it fails to recognize the crop’s benefits. There is a reason that palm oil has expanded so rapidly: it’s profitable and productive. Compared to other oil producing crops, like soy, coconut, and sunflower seed, palm oil produces three to ten times the amount of oil. Because of its productivity, palm oil is cheaper than other oils and is therefore found in many consumer products. If we banned palm oil, but continued our oil consumption trends, we’d need to use a lot more area to produce the same amount of oil. Plus, palm oil production is critical to national and local economies; many small farmers’ livelihoods depend on the crop.

Given recent palm oil growth in Latin America and the Caribbean, we as a development bank are evaluating palm oil’s varied impacts on the region. Colombia, for example, is already the fifth largest palm oil producer in the world and plans to increase production six fold  by 2020. The Honduran government is supporting an increase of more than 100,000 hectares of planted palm oil. Can the Latin American region benefit from palm oil while avoiding the devastating impacts experienced by Southeast Asia?

In 2004, The Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil was created to make palm oil production more sustainable; continuing its harvest while reducing negative environmental and social impacts. Any palm oil that is certified under RSPO should meet RSPO’s principles and criteria, which include environmental and social indicators. For example, RSPO certified companies may not clear forests with “high conservation values.”

However, RSPO still has a number of issues to sort out. On the business side, supply of RSPO certified palm oil is greater than demand, meaning that the premium paid for RSPO certified palm oil is low – about 2.3% higher than non-certified palm oil. As long as consumers don’t differentiate between RSPO and non-RSPO palm oil certified products, the price premium will remain low. The low return on the investment of certification discourages producers from pursuing RSPO; 20% of global palm oil supply is RSPO certified.

Another critique of RSPO comes from environmental and social advocates, who claim that RSPO members continue to act irresponsibly. RSPO principles and criteria only protect old growth forests and forests with high conservation value, meaning that secondary forests and peatlands are fair game for conversion to palm oil plantations. Moreover, a number of RSPO members are responsible for deforestation of forests that should have been protected, calling into question the ability of RSPO to police its members.

The Don

Palm oil producer

For these reasons and more, there is an ongoing debate about whether RSPO is the best means of reducing palm oil’s negative impacts.

Seeking to answer these questions, the IDB has partnered with an innovative palm oil processing company in Ecuador, La Fabril. La Fabril has committed to achieving RSPO certification – which includes certifying hundreds of its small-scale, independent suppliers. We’ll look at the business case for La Fabril to become RSPO certified in order to better understand companies’ motivations. Our study will also consider the environmental and social impacts of RSPO certification.

Given the explosion of palm oil in our region and the checkered history of the crop elsewhere, it’s critical not to repeat the same mistakes. Is RSPO an effective mechanism to clean up palm oil in Latin America and the Caribbean?

Last modified: Septiembre 12, 2016

4 Responses to " Is Investment in Palm Oil Certification Worth It? "

  1. Ogu Goodluck dice:

    Thanks for your article. I guess the story is also related to Nigeria. Can you please shed more light on the Roundtable discussion. Today a lot of small holders depend on this for living in mostly Eastern Nigeria. I am also an interested investor for oilpalm for the future. So I want to be a part of this story . Certifications can only move towards monoploy if not checked properly. The moment you put a clause on this kind of discussion, it will be necessary to factor in how the people without access to this kind of information can be factored in to save them and there families from the hope they have.

  2. SANATH dice:

    Dear sir,

    May I invite you to write more details of your work to me and we can have a discussion. I am interested in your effort.

    All good wishes

  3. Elisa dice:

    Palm oil industrial production means extensive plantations only, that is to say a huge amount of land that derives from deforestation, land grabbing and forced displacement. In a country like Colombia, for instance, plantations have been implemented after violent dispossession, forcing native people to leave their land and loose their food sovereignty, compelled to live in big cities where they are victims of the crime’s exploitation, especially women and kids. I really would like to see where, in Colombia, people who have lost their land because of agribusiness are living prosperously. In Colombia the extraction of natural resources is impoverishing the weaker strata of the population and the government is not protecting at all these citizens. So if palm oil is a positive investment it is so exclusively for the benefit of big companies and big land owners: post colonialism at its best, steal, flee and find another sub- developed weak country to rob.

Deja un comentario

Tu dirección de correo electrónico no será publicada. Los campos obligatorios están marcados con *